I am currently working on an oaxaca blinder decomposition on wage gap between males and females. A stata implementation of the blinderoaxaca decomposition core. Coefficient bar plots for the blinderoaxaca decomposition browse all. The blinderoaxaca decomposition technique is widely used to identify and quantify the separate contributions of group differences in measurable characteristics, such as education. This article introduces the r package oaxaca to perform the blinderoaxaca decomposition, a statistical method that decomposes the gap in mean outcomes across two groups into a portion that is due to differences in group characteristics and a portion that cannot be explained by such differences. A stata implementation of the blinderoaxaca decomposition. Stata module to compute the blinderoaxaca decomposition, statistical software components s456936, boston college department of economics, revised 25 aug 2011. Blinder oaxaca decomposition oaxaca performs a blinder oaxaca decomposition for linear regression models blinder, 1973. The counterfactual decomposition technique popularized by blinder 1973 and oaxaca 1973 is widely used to study mean outcome di. Since the topic of my thesis concerns gender inequalities among toplevel managers, decomposing the gender wage gap would. I would like to use the blinder oaxaca decomposition in my thesis. Stata module to compute the blinderoaxaca decomposition. Apart from this debate, the oaxacablinder decomposition can be used to assess the.
The procedure is an extension of the oaxaca blinder decomposition to nonlinear models. Statistical software components from boston college department of economics. Using the oaxacablinder decomposition technique to analyze. The decomposition method, the technique used for analyzing earnings differentials, was popularized in the economics literature by oaxaca 1973 and blinder 1973. I am trying to decompose the gender pay gap with the blinder oaxaca decomposition for ols regression twofold using. Data sources state inpatient databases sids for 2005 and 2006 from four diverse states were used to identify patients with stays for joint replacement, stroke, or hip fracture. Labor market and demographic data for employed hispanic. Blinderoaxaca decomposition with mixedeffect model with. Research report april 2017 how to analyze your gender. I would like to use the blinderoaxaca decomposition in my thesis. I know codes have been developed for stata but would like to know whether it is an option in sas as well. This article studies the relation between the oaxacablinder decomposition and the estimated coefficient of a dummy variable for a linear regression. Analyzing health equity using household survey data. The procedure is an extension of the oaxacablinder decomposition to nonlinear models.
Blinderoaxaca decomposition with mixedeffect model with r. This article introduces the r package oaxaca to perform the blinder oaxaca decomposition, a statistical method that decomposes the gap in mean outcomes across two groups into a portion that is due to differences in group characteristics and a portion that cannot be explained by such differences. Decomposing racial and ethnic disparities in the use of. I have not been able to find a suitable solution in r, and i am rather reluctant to create one myself i would probably mess it up. Astataimplementationoftheblinderoaxacadecomposition. Lecture on decomposition methods relies heavily on the chapter decomposition methods in economics joint with thomas lemieux and sergio firpo in the recent handbook of labor economics volume 4a, 2011 uses the classic work of oaxaca 1973 and blinder 1973 for the mean as its point of departure focuses on recent developments last 15 years on how to go beyond. An extension of the blinder oaxaca decomposition technique to logit and probit models robert w. His areas of research include labor economics, applied econometrics and applied microeconomics. A function has been written for r using the oaxaca decomposition. Oaxaca graduated from california state university, fresno in 1965, and went on to earn a ph. Thanks to kit baum, a new version of the oaxaca package is available from ssc. The blinderoaxaca decomposition for linear regression. Duncan 1968, and before that in demography kitagawa 1955. His areas of research include labor economics, applied econometrics and applied microeconomics oaxaca graduated from california state university, fresno in 1965, and went on to earn a ph.
The easiest way to estimate the oaxacablinder decomposition. Furthermore, atal, nopo andwinder 2009 although the decomposition blinder oaxaca is the approach most applied in research about wage differentials, it has three noteworthy flaws. Oaxacablinder as a reweighting estimator by patrick kline a large literature focuses on the use of propensity score methods as a semiparametric alternative to regression for estimation of average treatments e. Blinderoaxaca decomposition for linear and nonlinear models. Using the oaxaca blinder decomposition technique to analyze. Using the oaxacablinder decomposition technique to. First, the decomposition only gives information about the average wage gap omitting the different distribution of this gap among individuals of a same group. I am currently using the blinder oaxaca decomposition in one of my thesis. Oaxaca decomposition the oaxacablinder ob decomposition, independently developed by oaxaca and blinder in 1973, is a canonical tool for separating the in.
The idea unpacking the blinderoaxaca solution the blinderoaxaca decomposition methodology can be viewed as a package of two different ideas. Oaxacablinder decomposition for quantile regression sas. I read the article a stata implementation of the blinderoaxaca decomposition by jann2008. But i would like to use the blinderoaxaca decomposition for this model. Readers of analyzing health equity using household survey data may also be interested in a new computer program known as adepthealth that automates the methods outlined in the book, allowing users to produce quickly and with a minimal risk of errors most of the tables and charts in the book. Stata does have a package decomp for the oaxaca decomposition, but only for linear regression. Letting d be an indicator variable for group membership, yd be the scalar outcome of interest for a member of group d, xd be a row vector of observable. Dear forum i consider decomposing a gender wage gap by the oaxaca blinder method. Theoretical framework blinderoaxaca decomposition for linear models common assumptions about the form of the decomposition equations proposed by blinder 1973 and oaxaca 1973 represent special cases of the generalized equation in which. I have some basic knowledge of spss but i know that stata has a command called oaxaca. This article studies the relation between the oaxacablinder decomposition and the estimated coefficient of a dummy variable for a linear. This statistical method decomposes the difference in the means of outcome variables across two groups into a part that is due to crossgroup differences in explanatory variables and a part that is due to differences in groupspecific coefficients. Oaxaca decomposition 151 where diagd is the diagonal of d.
We calculate the unexplained part of the decomposition from the estimated coefficient of the dummy variable. The blinderoaxaca decomposition for linear regression models see stata journal 2008 number 4, pp. Blinderoaxaca decomposition oaxaca performs a blinderoaxaca decomposition for linear regression models blinder, 1973. Dear forum i consider decomposing a gender wage gap by the oaxacablinder method. The oaxacablinder ob approach is predicated upon a model for the potential outcomes of the form. It has been applied since in other social issues, including education, where it can be used to assess how much of a gap is due to differences in characteristics explained variation and how much is due to policy or system changes unexplained variation. Why is the value of this constant so big and what does this constant mean in the oaxaca blinder model. Computing a oaxaca decomposition is easy enough run ols and compute mean values of x for each of the two groups in stata, oaxaca. The oaxaca blinder technique was originally used in labor economics to decompose earnings gaps and to estimate the level of discrimination. The blinderoaxaca decomposition is a statistical method that explains the difference in the means of a dependent variable between two groups by decomposing the gap into that part that is due to differences in the mean values of the independent variable within the groups, on the one hand, and group differences in the effects of the independent variable, on the other hand. I read the article a stata implementation of the blinder oaxaca decomposition by jann2008. Is it ok to only compute oaxacablinder, or should i calculate its alternatives reimers, cotton, neumark. An extension of the blinderoaxaca decomposition technique to.
Analyzing health equity using household survey data world bank. Oaxaca decomposition 149 the gap between the mean outcomes, ynonpoor and ypoor, is equal to 12. The blinderoaxaca decomposition for linear regression models. For example, the technique is often used to analyze wage gaps by sex or race. This command performs aggregate and detailed decompositions of the average outcome differential between two groups. What is the difference between oaxacablinder decomposition and interaction terms in a linear equation. Oaxaca blinder decomposition in stata with survey weights. In this article, a general blinderoaxaca decomposition for nonlinear models is derived, which allows the difference in an outcome variable between two groups to be decomposed into several components.
An extension of the blinderoaxaca decomposition technique to logit and probit models. Older versions of this routine are available as oaxaca9 and oaxaca8. The oaxacablinder technique was originally used in labor economics to decompose earnings gaps and to estimate the level of discrimination. Blinderoaxaca decomposition any step by step guide for. Stata module to compute the blinder oaxaca decomposition. This article studies the relation between the oaxaca blinder decomposition and the estimated coefficient of a dummy variable for a linear regression. Marginal effects and extending the blinderoaxaca decomposition to nonlinear models. How to interpret the constant in oaxaca blinder decomposition. This paper describes the application of a semiparametric approach, known as a varying coefficients model hastie and tibshirani 1993, to implement a oaxaca blinder type of decomposition in the presence of selfselection into treatment groups for a continuum of comparison groups. An extension of the blinderoaxaca decomposition technique. To determine the degree to which racial and ethnic disparities in the use of postacute rehabilitation care parc are explained by observed characteristics. Adepthealth dramatically reduces the time taken to prepare standard health equity tables, and makes more widely accessible all the methods covered in analyzing health equity using household survey data. Tamas bartus 5 extending the blinderoaxaca decomposition to nonlinear models i.
Using oaxaca decomposition to study socioeconomic inequity of. This module should be installed from within stata by typing ssc install oaxaca. Blinderoaxaca decomposition in r by marek hlavac ssrn. Blinderoaxaca decomposition any step by step guide for newbies. Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance. Download the accompanying data and code for this guide at. The flexibility of this methodology may allow for detecting heterogeneity of the role of endowment. I am trying to decompose the gender pay gap with the blinderoaxaca decomposition for ols regression twofold using. C14,c21,j31,j71 abstract this chapter provides a comprehensive overview of decomposition methods that have been developed since the seminal work of oaxaca and blinder in the early 1970s. For a practical overview of how the oaxacablinder decomposition is implemented by researchers at the world bank, see odonnell, owen et al. The command can accomodate all generalized linear models that can be fit with the stata command glm. Relies heavily on the chapter decomposition methods in economics joint with thomas lemieux and sergio firpo in the recent handbook of labor economics volume 4a, 2011 uses the classic work of oaxaca 1973 and blinder 1973 for the mean as its point of departure focuses on recent developments last 15 years on how to go beyond. This document outlines a series of works developed over several decades from the original and independent works of blinder 1973 and oaxaca 1973 with the aim of facilitating the comprehension of the technique for wage decomposition and its methodological improvements and applications over time. It provide the twofold and threefold decomposition describe in bauer and sinning 2008, as the characteristic, coef.
We show how, using nldecompose, this general decomposition can be applied to different models with discrete and limited dependent variables. The blinderoaxaca decomposition method has been used extensively to assess mean. Decomposition methods in economics nicole fortin, thomas lemieux, and sergio firpo nber working paper no. The blinderoaxaca decomposition for nonlinear regression. Generaloaxaca general blinderoaxaca decomposition description blinderoaxaca decomposition for generalized linear model. Wage gap between men and women in tunisia hela jeddi and dhafer malouche november 10, 2015 abstract this paper focuses on estimating wage di erences between males and females in tunisia by using the oaxacablinder decomposition, a technical that isolates wage gap due to characteristics, from wage gap due to discrimination against women. For a practical overview of how the oaxacablinder decomposition is implemented by. I am using the oaxaca blinder two fold decomposition in stata. Fairlie abstract the blinder oaxaca decomposition technique is widely used to identify and quantify the separate contributions of group differences in measurable characteristics, such as education. After inequalities in the health sector are measured, a natural next step is to seek to. Evidence from glassdoor salary data, glassdoor economic research study. Blinder, 1973 separating the effect of differences in characteristics and returns for both. The data here is derived from the american time use survey.
919 444 391 1024 614 132 819 807 813 764 927 1274 1044 667 98 776 385 1481 1495 1571 1215 697 1470 1366 832 985 491 1391 1230 140 846 272 1638 1477 556 1205 1032 1323 574 1417 1353 425 962 1020 321 108 1389